Publication

Integrated Simulation of Blackstart Grid Restoration with Cognitive Operator Modeling Control Implementation

Casey L. Doyle; Kevin L. Stamber; Robert G. Abbott; Aaron P. Jones; Bryan Arguello; Richard A. Garrett; Walter E. Beyeler; David A. Schoenwald; Samuel T. Ojetola

2023
2023 IEEE International Conference on Communications, Control, and Computing Technologies for Smart Grids (SmartGridComm)
Publisher / DOI

Abstract

Efficient restoration of electrical grids from a complete shutdown (i.e. ‘blackstart’) is nontrivial and critical to the safety and resiliency of communities. The problem is well studied from an optimization perspective; grids are analyzed and a set of blackstart plans are created so they are ready for an operator to follow them in an effort to restore the system. However, most existing approaches don’t explicitly account for time, and assume a known network state and full observability and control by grid operators which is not always the case. Here, we introduce a technique for the integrated modeling of optimized restoration plans with a cognitive simulation of operator actions. To this end, we built the CogTasks simulation library that allows for the cognitively sound simulation of hierarchical tasking and problem solving to serve as the basis of the grid operator model. We utilize a power flow-informed restoration framework to generate optimal restoration plans that are then enacted by our cognitive agent on a a dynamic representation of the grid. We show that utilizing this cognitive agent introduces extra noise and stability considerations into the implementation of the restoration plan; while the optimization reward function is still reasonably well correlated with the observed restoration time in our tests, this integrated model reveals value to including operator limitations and actions in restoration planning and lends explainability to the optimized schedules.

AI Summary

This paper integrates optimized black-start planning with a cognitive simulation of grid-operator execution so restoration performance can be evaluated under more realistic human and system constraints. The authors develop the CogTasks library to represent hierarchical operator tasks and problem solving, use a power-flow-informed optimization framework to generate restoration plans, and have a cognitive agent execute those plans on a dynamic grid model. In the reported tests, adding the operator model introduces timing variability and additional stability considerations that are absent from the optimization-only plan, while the optimization reward remains reasonably correlated with the realized restoration time. The integrated simulation therefore exposes differences between an optimal schedule and how restoration unfolds when operator actions and limitations are represented. The work demonstrates that cognitive modeling can improve the realism and explainability of black-start restoration studies and provides a basis for evaluating restoration plans as operational procedures rather than purely mathematical schedules.

Full Paper

The full paper is available from the publisher or an authoritative repository.

View Published Version ↗